Why the Public Cloud is a Big Fat Enterprise #Fail

With the advent of the consumer driven enterprise, there are now two ways to define the success of a platform.

With the advent of the consumer driven enterprise, there are now two ways to define the success of a platform. One is to look at adoption rates and declare a platform successful based on how many people are using it. By that measure, the public cloud is a smashing enterprise success.

Billions of users worldwide are using public cloud services such as Dropbox, Google Drive (formerly Docs), Skype, Evernote, YouTube and, yes, even Facebook to do business with colleagues, customers, partners and vendors.  atmosphere-clouds

But the other way to define platform success is to look at what businesses, organizations and institutions are actually investing in and encouraging people to use. By that measure, the public cloud is a resounding enterprise flop. Every one of the public cloud services I just mentioned top the list of blacklisted apps in the enterprise. And that list keeps growing.

Moreover, adoption of Google Apps appears to be sputtering, despite reports from the company. Still with the beefed up version of Google Docs, Google Drive, now available, Google Apps is certainly one of the highest profile public cloud platforms.

Now, you could argue this shows CIOs and their IT teams are clueless, and they prove that by saying “no” and pushing back against consumerization in the enterprise. Rather than use Dropbox, IT insists on using Sharepoint. Rather than use Skype, IT requires WebEx. And so on.

I would argue, however, that it’s the public cloud services vendors who are, in fact, clueless. Large enterprises continue to embrace private clouds. IT organizations increasingly understand the risks, opportunities, roles and potential benefits of public and private cloud computing. And they’re largely putting their chips on the private cloud card.

If I were running a public cloud service, I’d be worried about IT blacklists and private clouds used to meet requirements that could be served more quickly and cost-effectively by a public cloud solution. I’d be asking IT leaders why they’re attracted to private clouds and repelled, overall, from the public cloud. And I’d start transforming my offering to give IT what it needs.

Enterprise IT leaders want tight security in public cloud services and SaaS apps. They want to ensure compliance with HIPAA, FISMA, SOXand other regulations. They need enterprise data encrypted at rest and in motion. They need directory services integration. They need disaster recovery. They can’t afford high latency, downtime or a single data breach. The list goes on.

Let’s use Amazon’s AWS public cloud as an example. When you shut down a workload, that workload is gone and is unrecoverable. If a user accidentally shuts down a workload, everything they were working on vanishes.

From Amazon’s perspective, that’s your problem. You’re expected to have backup and disaster recovery systems in place. You’re expected to design applications for failure rather than design for continuity. You have no control over continuity in the infrastructure, so you have to code it into each and every public cloud application.

Simultaneously meeting the needs of consumers, while addressing the needs of IT leaders, is exactly how a small company named Microsoft evolved the original consumerization of IT — personal computers running DOS and Windows — from a rogue device into a primary platform.

Public cloud technology vendors would do well to reuse that model. Giving consumers what they want, even to the extent of providing tools and support to help users bypass their IT departments, might be an effective way to quickly grow a user base. But it’s a dead end over the long haul.

Certainly consumers’ needs should be met. But give the IT organizations that support them the tools they need to provision, integrate, authenticate, secure, manage, automate, monitor and audit. Instead, however, the majority of public cloud vendors are counting on the consumer driven enterprise to force-feed their solutions into the enterprise.

The growth of the public cloud proves consumers want change. The growth of private clouds proves IT is open to change. If we don’t want to see the blacklists get longer, public cloud vendors must start listening to IT if they hope to succeed in the enterprise. By coming together, the cloud overall becomes more productive, safe, and effective for everyone.


Written by

Andi Mann

CA Leadership

Andi is VP of Strategic Solutions at CA Technologies and an expert across cloud, mainframe,…

Published in

View this topic
  • James Holland

    This is great. Hooray for Disney’s imagineers!

  • http://www.sheistocktips.com/ SHRISTOCKTIPS

    become a new brand in the share market research with its accurate research. Proven
    itself always right whether market is bull or bear. Last week all paid clients
    booked handsome profit in NIFTY, BANKINIFTY & STOCKS. Now for the coming
    week we expect more correction can come in NIFTY as the IRAQ issue is getting
    more tense, If it happens more then you will see a sharp fall in all world marketNSE BSE, STOCK TIPSbecause as we know all world run on
    crude & most of the crude comes from IRAQ. So be ready for a sharp fall so
    sell will be the best strategy for next week also. Traders can make a sell
    position in NIFTY around 7600-7650 with stoploss 7750 for the target of
    7300-7200.One can also make a sell call NIFTY 50 stocks as per NIFTY levels. You
    can also take our two days free trial to check our accuracy. For further updates
    you can visit our website. http://goo.gl/sMgZ7n



  • king lear

    testing comment functionality, please do not publish this

  • http://www.rachelmacik.com Rachel Macik

    Love the personal pic :)

    • CAHighlight

      Thank you!

  • Plutora Inc

    This is a good case study. 2.3 sec’s off a login transaction is big.

  • http://www.linkedin.com/in/michelehudnall Michele Hudnall

    While the analysts were hyping DevOps, I posted the oversight of not including security as part of that discussion as you are highlighting here. Instead of just talking DevOps, it should be DOS (what’s old is new again :-) – DevOpsSec. As a previous AppDev person, it’s the app, who’s using it, why and where rather than the device and having the service available.

    As you rightly point, out Security should be baked into the solution.

    Nice Post and Timely!


    • CAHighlight

      Thank you for your feedback Michele. Agreed – security cannot be overlooked. Appreciate your input!

  • Mitesh

    I would love a printed copy

  • Lars Johansson

    I love the idea of BYOID! This makes me choose if I am almost anonymous (with my Hotmail Nicname) or official with identity from an official organisation. My Identity Provider will attach identity with right level of LoA according to the need of the Service provider.

    • CAHighlight

      Thank you for your comment. BYOID has tangible benefits for end users and relying parties but it also has to be weighed in the balance with potential risks and liability concerns. It will be interesting to see how BYOID plays out in the enterprise.